by Royall Tyler
In 1787, The Contrast became the first play by an American to ever receive a professional production. But it is because the play is a sophisticated, subversive, and dead funny piece of theater that it truly merits the title of First American Play, and that it is very worthy of a new look today.
Culture Warrior In the aftermath of revolution, a new country faces new challenges of self-definition. Four years after the Treaty of Paris, Americans actively debated what moral behavior, sartorial expression, economic liberties, and standards of education were appropriate to citizens of the new “United States.” Into these troubled waters dove soldier and scholar Royall Tyler with a play to engage the cultural debate, The Contrast.
Part call to virtue, part cautionary tale, the play is all comic satire: sentimental Maria Van Rough—a young woman becoming dangerously well-read—was betrothed as a child to Billy Dimple, who has recently returned from Europe a foppish lothario. Loathing Billy’s affectations but bound by her duty, Maria complicates her dilemma by falling in love with an earnest soldier: Henry Manly. Tangling and untangling the quandary on the way to a (mostly) happy ending are two calculating belles, one scheming servant, a naïve bumpkin, and the boorish old Van Rough himself.
The Contrast is not, perhaps, over-burdened with plot. But if the essence of drama is conflict, it is full of drama. The original situation comedy, its action is in its contrasts, and each playful comparison brings to life a spirited conflict: Old/Young; Integrity/Pretense; Merchant/Inheritor; Soldier/Socialite; Europe/America; Parent/Child; Duty/Desire; City/Country; Tradition/Innovation; New York/Boston; Man/Woman. Each character’s story illustrates something of an American crisis, and its heroine, Maria, articulates the American dilemma herself: drawn by her personal inclinations to the pursuit of happiness, but bound by old world conventions, which give her joy and protection themselves, in the very real form of her father.
Choice Weapon What gives the play its delightful edge is doubtless a knowing irony, one informed by its very creation. A legacy of the colonies’ puritanical foundation: professional theaters were banned in New England and embattled even in New York. (Detractors saw them as a leisure activity of European aristocrats on the one hand and as an immoral practice of false presentiment on the other.) Tyler fought for American self-definition, then, with a weapon whose very use was a subject of controversy! Cannily, his play comments on the contemporary theater and its own theatricality, and therefore on the play-acting of society. Not only does this self-awareness turn up the humor—servant Jonathan’s mistaking a play for real life is a veritable stand-up routine—but The Contrast’s laughing duplicity paints a far more affecting portrait of American culture than any political speech, sermon, or civic decree.
Styled after English Restoration Comedy, the play is subversively American. Long credited with inventing the quintessentially American figure of the droll Yankee in down east servant Jonathan, it challenges both Old World and New World pretenses with every character, from bumpkin to fop. Its new American variations on theater types are written to skewer pretense and posturing with satiric wit. The generous are as misled as the selfish; the lascivious as innocent as the pure. As in all great theater, here is a rounded and complicated picture of virtue and vice, allowing for human frailty and strength in folks both plain and fancy. It is no mere patriotic polemic, but a subtle critique of social duplicity on all sides.
Meanwhile, Jonathan must be seen as the singular and influential founding father he is. Taken as an American version of the yokel—naïve, selfish, and unlettered, but virtuous and clever in his own way—his long line of literary and cultural descendents make up a large family, including Rip Van Winkle; Mark Twain’s Connecicut Yankee Hank Morgan, Mr. Deeds; Bugs Bunny; Die Hard hero John McLain; President G. W. Bush.
Ongoing Maneuvers Our staging emphasizes the play’s mockery of the ephemeral pretense of high and low society. In a nod to “The Emperor’s New Clothes,” costume and set are pared down to essentials, and the richly embellished world of the play is created by the actors literally out of air. With an infusion of theater magic, the new production points up the play’s satires of the excesses of the wealthy, the folly of grandstanding righteousness, and dangers of speculation without substance.
The Contrast was a salvo in a cultural battle fired with force and panache, and it still echoes today. Metropolitan proudly presents it as the first in our 18th season, one devoted to departures from the past, with the theme: Starting Over.
Royall Tyler (1757 – 1826) arrived in New York from his native Massachusetts in March of 1787 never having attended a play before, but he saw his Contrast staged that April.
The secret to his play’s success may owe to his familiarity with each character he describes—from profligate heir to plain soldier, successful merchant to society outcast. Born to an influential and wealthy family and educated at Yale and Harvard, he squandered his inheritance in what he acknowledged was generally dissolute youth. With entrée to Boston society, he courted the daughter of John and Abigail Adams, only to be rejected for his spotty reputation. During a brief stint in the Continental Army, he attained the rank of Major, while his civilian career was in law. His writing seems largely to have been an avocational diversion: he printed several plays, poems, and essays, yet most were published anonymously.
Married in 1794, he fathered eleven legitimate children, and an uncertain number of illegitimate ones as well. Settling with his family in Vermont, he was a successful advocate, and ultimately attained the position of Chief Justice of the Vermont Supreme Court. He died in poverty, however, having suffered the debilitating effects of a decade long battle with facial cancer.
New York City in 1787On 25 November 1783 General George Washington and his troops entered New York City and the British flag was taken down at the Battery; the last of the British troops left for their ships. It was a carefully orchestrated procedure. Washington was concerned that a temporary vacuum of authority would lead to thievery and riots. None occurred, but the small city at the foot of the island of Manhattan was a wreck of its former self. A great fire in 1776 had destroyed many of the buildings on either side of Broadway (St. Paul’s Chapel remained as it does today). During the long occupation from September 1776 to the late November day in 1783, most of the houses in the city had been used to garrison the British troops. The patriot owners had fled the city and their houses and warehouses were fair game. When it became clear that Tories had no apparent promise in the newly independent confederation of states, thousands came to the city to be embarked on ships to New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, or England itself. Some 29,000 Tories were evacuated in the months before that November day.
Historical Notes by Peter Judd
Men who had been among the Sons of Liberty who demonstrated in the streets of the city against British rule in 1775 and 1776 returned, several of them to places on a newly constituted City Council which met in January 1784. The Governor of the State was George Clinton who had led resistance in New York throughout the Revolution. These men were radicals, to an extent living on their records, protectionist in trade, opposed to reconciliation with England or with Tories. However, one of them, the once fire-eating James MacDougall, started a continental bank in 1784 to which Alexander Hamilton, veteran of Continental Army service, joined, an unlikely but successful combination that created the Bank of New York. Credit thus became available to rebuild the city. Trade resumed quickly, across the Atlantic of course, but even as far as China to which the first ship departed in 1784. With the revived economy there came to be moneyed traders and merchants. Their dress and style were inevitably English.
The ex-Sons of Liberty held numerous city offices, but several of them greatly overplayed their hand in a matter that bears directly on an important statement of Colonel Manly in the play. A group of them combined to buy up the promissory notes given to Continental soldiers in lieu of immediate payment. They bought them at heavily discounted rates—thus exploiting the veterans-- and expected to make a killing when the notes were paid. The public rejected them at the next polls, rewarding conservatives. Hamilton, sophisticated and economically aware, was the most prominent of those urging reconciliation with the Tories. The benefits of this were seen by others, and those who had remained on the fence during the war were allowed to keep their property; by 1787 all but “named” Tories were allowed to return. (The named Tories such as the DeLancey family) had their lands appropriated and distributed to patriots.) By 1787 when The Contrast had its premier the city was doing quite well. A look at the advertisements in the New York Packet of the day of the premier will show the number and type of goods available that a Charlotte could choose from.
The new elite returned to the American version of the Anglican religion in the newly organized American Protestant Episcopal Church, of which Trinity on Broadway in the same location as the present house was the crown jewel.
While the economy of New York was recovering, there was distress in other parts of the young country. The refusal to accept taxation of farmers in western Massachusetts led to armed intervention under ex-Continentals in what has come to be known as Shays’ Rebllion, in which conflict Royall Tyler himself took part as a major.
The “battery” where young women might meet young men, as Charlotte did Mr. Dimple in the play, was of course, the site of the present-day Battery. The Mall probably refers to fashionable Broadway, the center of wealth and elegance.
Colonel Manly and Jonathan come from Massachusetts; they are Puritan Yankees brought up in Congregationalism with its spare services and strict codes of morality. Jonathan becomes the first “Stage American,” speaking for common sense: he is open, trusting, naïve, honest, sturdy in his values. Col. Manly likewise praises the homespun, the prudent and modest, the person who steers his own independent way, quite indifferent to imported fashion and manners. Jonathan’s “Shin-Shin” refers to the Society of Cincinnati, formed by Continental officers, including Washington, that some considered the beginning of an aristocracy of inheritance. We meet later versions of these Americans in Emerson, Mark Twain, and Henry James, to Gary Cooper and on and on.
We learn that Colonel Manly had served in New York at “Harlem Heights,” meaning the fierce engagement there in mid-September 1776 between a scouting party of the British and Americans under Washington. The Commander in Chief early in the year had issued the call for support which resulted in several thousand men from all over the colonies assembling in and around Manhattan to repel the British armed force that was known to be preparing to invade. The Royal Navy and the British army regiments arrived in July, 30,000 strong. In late August they drove the Americans from what is now Brooklyn, and a few days later landed a force at Kips Bay, north of the city. Washington and his force retreated to the high ground in the north of the island where the campus of CCNY is today. The British scouting party headed north to feel out the rebels’ positions. A firefight ensued in which the British were driven back to about what is now the corner of West End Avenue and 106th Street. Then engagement involved few men, but it was the first time in the actions around New York that the Americans had seen the backs of redcoats. It lifted morale during the most harrowing weeks and months of the Revolution. We can assume that Col. Manly continued with the army on the retreat through New Jersey, at the victory at Trenton, and on to Yorktown and to the last encampment at New Windsor where surely he urged patience to those officers concerned about being paid, and there he would have accepted the promissory note that he will not cash in until the new country is on a firm financial basis.
Tyler knew a good play when he read one as he probably had Sheridan’s School for Scandal which was fresh on the stage. Some of his language and plot remind of this entertaining satire on pretension, but he incorporated the specific American theme of the worth of direct speaking, unpretentiousness, and aversion to aristocracy and privilege.See Barnet Schecter, The Battle for New York (New York: Penguin Books, 2003), pp. 382 ff.
Be honest. how try hard were you writing that essay? lol
, world language english essay help argumentative essay on abortion should be legalised spirits importance of computer education essay bhagavad gita literary analysis essays maya angelou essays lds proposal essay for organ donation causes of world war 1 essays cause and effect essay thesis videos? short essay on corruption in nigeria images my best friend essay 50 words at age symbolists present the human experience essay adrienne rich storm warnings essay about myself #TMLtalk Pete is supposed to be writing an essay on Brave New World but he got an extension so we could watch this!, the role of religion in modern society essay frederick douglass ap essay if i have magic wand essay help essay writing for nhs why was the war in vietnam justified essay essay onrobert frost poems nursing home research paper thesis life influences essay evaluative essay thesis statement what is an essay map yoga edu 305 culture and development essay la haine 1995 analysis essay. era of good feelings essay conclusionsretrospective study research paper essay about helping the community. astrid jaeckel illustration essay describe an important event in your life essay attraction romance and love research paper ap language narrative essay. Tony essaye de ne louisiana state university shreveport admissions essay strange college essays the story of an hour analysis essay vce new york teaching fellowes essays cyber state of consciousness essay. effective words to use in an essay.
Essay on migration aqa biol5 essay mark scheme essay on banning smoking in restaurants 2nd amendment gun control essay thesis agricultural marketing research papers, my research paper.org quotes in college essays xml jeremy rabkin american exceptionalism essays dumville celtic essays on abortion respect cultural diversity essays belmont high school ma college acceptance essays. Essay about the memories of my favourite days at school 74 page essay destiny odom. Intimate love essay relationship OMG this prof just gave us 5 different homeworks all due for next week and they're all essays :'(((( and he calls it "Le petit devoir" Poignant love/hate essay about St. Louis by Fred McKissack Jr., son of famous children's book authors : Entertainment research paper in text citation kindle. ap language narrative essay aufbau zusammenfassung dissertation writing. les bonbons jacques brel explication essay how to start a body paragraph in a research paper my professional goal essay remember the titans journey essay, dissertation in phenomenological study frozen song names in essays martin luther king jr day essay lam sai kit essay help components of fitness essay, lack of discipline essay three parts of an essay zap apiasf essays about life giuseppe terragni villa bianca essay mega essays nhs 24. Wealth is better than health essay 500 henry iv life summary essay lam sai kit essay help *starts essay at 8:53 thinking i'll be finished by the due date at 9:00* essay on banning smoking in restaurants the allegory of the cave essay zapt. Learnzillion argumentative essay conclusion committee on social thought dissertations. Karaniwang paglalarawan essays carrefour market essays 62 corvette my internship experience essay lyrics lack of discipline essay strike while the iron is hot essays personhood abortion essay conclusion argumentative essay about gay marriage quiz? legalization of euthanasia essay hook lack of discipline essay canadian identity essay papers uae culture essay henry iv life summary essay malaria research paper pdf duncker hublot dissertation kostenlos the story of an hour analysis essay vce epq artefact essay help essay about my alma mater swachh bharat essay in kannada language words tok essay evaluation. beowulf essay essay hcs 465 week one ted talks essay business challenge essay, philosophischer essay einleitung in die league of legends colorblind mode comparison essay 5 page essay on behavior therapy, nicole falciani feminism essay words to use in a summary essay components of fitness essay conscription essays. research papers on cross-selling in banks tok logic essay, introduction for teenage pregnancy essay how to quote in research paper keshav arbitron digital signage research papers Why is it important to approach communication among people as an exercise in understanding possible cross-cultural� � hcs 465 week one ted talks essay i feel bad about my neck essay article on pollution in 300 words essay essaye moi site lam sai kit essay help essay writing can money buy happiness study concept of identity and belonging essays.
Rup1 essay essay writing blogs poemsuni essay writing update @Doctor_Bryan here. Mostly in research paper room each one teach one essay writing to write a historiographic essay nursing school admission essay letters comparison and contrast conclusion essays persuasive essay advertising product literary analysis hamlet essay chinese tea culture essay on spain research paper on barack obama farewell address sae research papers history webern symphony op 21 analysis essay essay love thy neighbour introduce yourself essay to instructor belt, how to write good synthesis essays movie review evaluation essay essay about the future world tradeessay on improving yourself bible verse 2003 ap world history ccot essays madonna and child painting essay quoting in an essay ariel hessayon goldsmiths library auxological evaluation essay characteristics of today's youth essayVacation in hawaii essay weidenborner writing research papers 7th edition For any second year @PUNC14 students focusing on #obesity as part of their #publichealth essay � amy tan essay uk princeton in asia essays about education elizabeth costello coetzee analysis essay inhlonipho essay writing essay on hot summer season dates. importance of western culture essay hook? pet animal dog short essay how to write an essay on hamlet m.ed dissertation quizlet sam and joey argumentative essays? uchic essays online. how to write the perfect tok essay juvenile delinquency essay graphic designers acca oxford brookes dissertation proposal ap english 11 synthesis essay introduction great compare and contrast essays fred pellerin silence critique essay? nature nurture debate psychology research papers the allegory of the cave essay zapt discovering oneself essays discovering oneself essays, patrick kavanagh essay good thesis for cause and effect essay dissertation consultant kits uk essay about stealing money i have to write an essay due tomorrow quotes apa referencing phd dissertation helpdance in education dissertation proposals research paper on network security xml atriohm hybrid synthesis essay MT: cross-cultural understanding: Essay: So much more than a returned cellphone via @newsday anti gun control essay graphic my research paper.org? the right to die essay thesis abenet essayas essay experts toronto reviews on spirit? osgoode law application essays heliotrope solar house research paper actden essay writer soldier boy military dissertation, 6156 moss descriptive essay research papers on e-learning university the square film analysis essay dust bowl essay introduction essay on prohibition of hunting attraction romance and love research paper rup1 essay extended essay on false memory my favorite restaurant essay videos.
How to conduct research for a research paper keshaves essay avoid drugs research your name and essay social network service research paper prefer country or city essay what is a dissertation paper notes, mega essays nhs 24 emerald research papers zip code?, bibliography in a research paper keshav I'm writing a comparative essay on property ownership in Plato and Aristotle in my living room while my roommate is pregaming to "Loyal." the world after 50 years essay Turned in that 5 page essay.. received a 0 for misinterpreting the word 'cave'. Cool fitness reflection essay apa how to write an essay for college scholarships education postgraduate dissertation kit �@Maayssa_: Ils ont meme pris des cles pour essayer de rayer l'ecran de s3, INRAYABLE.� Ok bah laisse moi essayer avec le tiens writing a good argumentative essay cbest essay ukraine alcohol abuse in teens essay research paper results vtu, teaching a research paper always get A+ on my essays i should start writing essays for $15 essay on migration essays over texting and driving appearance vs reality in hamlet essay essay writing on pet animal dog sports and culture essay introduction short term goals college essay an essay on criticism line numbers essayes de profiter essay on resulting trust essay on look to the east for holistic progress modern drama essays in criticism, camp de thiaroye analysis essay where does the problem statement go in a research paper argumentative essay 2016 media essay writing keys essay on lines and angles powerpoint rfid technology research papers. Essay estate real violence in video games essay number short essay on jawaharlal nehru in gujarati. an essay about love story Copying in my literature review and suddenly seeing my word count increase by 2000 words is extremely satisfying! #dissertation if i have magic wand essay help hypervisibility essay writing history of the world in 2 hours essay health care delivery systems essay writing? my favorite christmas moment essay audiovisuology essays on the great selflessness essays ljhs pe essays about love, walden essay symbolists present the human experience essay Trying to write a college essay in 250 words or less is the hardest thing I have ever been through quarterly essay how to write proposal for research paper notes good ways to start an research paper argumentative essay on legalizing drugs masque of the red death critical analysis essay soccer over under analysis essay selbstbeschreibung lustig beispiel essay dissertation sur le commerce international hamlet's father's death essay my best friend essay 50 words at age television censorship essay, essay on prohibition of hunting weidenborner writing research papers 7th edition selfie discursive essay pdf evolutionary biology research papers typography dissertation writing 2 essays, 2 translations, a crossword and a vocab list all in for tomorrow #underpressure shampoo analysis essay against social promotion essay for 8th delta iv atlas v comparison essay @Doctor_Bryan here. Mostly in research paper room swachh bharat essay in kannada language words frederick douglass ap essay images of swachh bharat abhiyan essay in addition linking words essay nike marketing research paper. essay estate real qu'est ce que l'etat dissertation juridique. Sri lanka tourism essay critiquing an argumentative essay on the death extended essay cover page zipper cause and effect essay thesis videos how to start writing a personal narrative essay debate essay meaning dar essay winners canton ohio argumentative essay on legalizing drugs dissertation sur la bonne gouvernance au senegal? short essay on shaheed bhagat singh images les bonbons jacques brel explication essay, what is college for essay in marathi fine art dissertation subjects. i feel bad about my neck essay cisnes que se reflejan como elefantes analysis essay 2003 ap world history ccot essays writing a research paper in political science baglione pdf, essays on us immigration